briarwood: (SW Yoda Pissed)
Morgan Briarwood ([personal profile] briarwood) wrote2009-02-27 03:49 pm

Audiobook frustration!

Crap like this is why people download stuff illegally!

I know Anne Bishop's latest Black Jewels novel is coming out in audiobook format. I didn't actually expect to find it in a format I can use but I gave it a try. Guess what I found?

Not only is Shadow Queen not available on CD, I found a ton of other audio novels I really, really want that are available only in download format and only in the USA. You can register on these sites, but unless you have a US (or in some cases Canada, too) address, you can't actually purchase the download version. And there's no CD version to buy.

I can't ask a US friend to buy them for me 'cause they'll be protected files; I need a regular or an MP3 CD that I can import into my own account.

I mean, WHY? What do they gain by cutting out half of their potential market? Seriously, Guy Gavriel Kay, Kelley Armstrong - they have strong European sales of their books. What's wrong with letting me pay for audio versions, too???

And I couldn't find a torrent for them either, but I'm gonna keep looking. If they won't let me spend good money on 'em, they can't blame me for torrenting instead.

And just to cap off my frustrating search of the latest audio releases...why is Chapterhouse Dune available but not Heretics of Dune, which preceeds it?

[identity profile] morgan32.livejournal.com 2009-02-27 04:42 pm (UTC)(link)
I get the licensing issue, but that's true of music, too, and it doesn't stop them making music CDs as well as downloads.

It's also true of paper books but I can still buy them internationally. This idiotic restriction only seems to apply to audiobooks.
ext_8559: Cartoon me  (Default)

[identity profile] the-magician.livejournal.com 2009-02-27 05:21 pm (UTC)(link)
Actually, no.

Sometimes Amazon will pop up a note saying that this item is available for sale in the US and Canada only. Similarly that is often in the front pages of books.

If you travelled as often as I have, you'd find books on the other side of security at Heathrow that are not for sale in the UK.

The publishers don't usually mind a small number of grey imports for places like SF book dealers at cons etc. but if the US got the Harry Potter books a month before the UK, WH Smith would not be selling the US versions and Amazon.com would probably not honour your purchase.

Some dealers ignore the restrictions and sell internationally anyway, but then it is them that are violating the terms of sale and them that are opening themselves up to a lawsuit.

[identity profile] morgan32.livejournal.com 2009-03-01 07:53 am (UTC)(link)
Nonsense.

Sometimes Amazon will pop up a note saying that this item is available for sale in the US and Canada only.

For physical products you'll only ever see that on software and even then the "marketplace" part of Amazon isn't so restricted. Besides, this is done only so they can charge higher prices in Europe - the actual product is available here, just not from that source.

You may be right about Harry Potter, but that's an exception to just about every publishing rule. Amazon have been internationally supplying books, videos, DVDs etc. that are supposedly only available in the US since the site began. It's one of the ways they got so big.

My point is not about legalities but about the reality of the situation. Whatever the licensing says, I can as a consumer legally obtain music, film, physical books and software that is published in the USA. Just not TV shows - and like you, I obtain on bittorrent those shows not available to me here - and, apparently, audiobooks. I am willing, even eager to spend money on these things and it seems nonsensical to me that I'm prevented from doing so.